This post rounds out some of my work of the last week.
- Emotions and music
- CNN, AOL, Yahoo, and many other websites covered the cognitive shuffle
- Pre-print to my somnolent information processing theory paper
- Detailed functional specification for Hookmark
- On the receiving end of professional coaching
- A new book proposal in progress
- Somnolence+
1. Emotions and music
This week, I didn’t publish much. I was mostly focused on reading about music-related emotions, for a chapter of my new book Discontinuities: Love, Art, Mind. Some of the ideas that will figure in this chapter:
- I will review evolutionary explanations of musical emotions. This explanation will extend an earlier discussion in the book of evolutionary explanations of art.
-
There is a fundamental distinction between perceived emotions and felt emotions. The former are emotions that appear to be expressed by the artwork. The latter are emotions elicited by the artwork.
- Making sense of music-related emotions requires that we be clear what we mean by emotion. Unfortunately, the literature is quite muddled in this respect. In an earlier chapter of the book, I outline several concepts of emotion. I argue that we should not merely use the word “emotion” but indicate which theory grounds the particularl concepts of emotion to which one is referring. This is not as academic as it may sound.
- I will present several ideas published by Winfried Menninghaus. (Use a translation tool on that page if you don’t read German.) At the top of this post there is a mind map of their theory, which I drew in OmniGraffle.
- There is no single mechanism through which music elicits emotion. Here I will summarize Emotional responses to music: the need to consider underlying mechanisms, which with subsequent work presents 8 contributors to musical emotions. They are summed up by the acronym BRECVEMA (a mnemonic for which is “Breakfast, Vehicle Ma). Each letter stands for a distinct mechanism:
- Brain stem reflexes
- Rhythmic entrainment
- Evaluative conditioning
- Contagion (emotional contagion)
- Visual imagery
- Episodic memory
- Musical expectancy
- Aesthetic judgment (added in later revisions of the model)
- I’ll review arguments about a hot topic in the field, i.e., whether and how aesthetic emotions are distinct from other kinds of emotion.
- I’ll review the argument from The emotional power of musical performance by Daniel Leech-Wilkinson that scores are fairly abstract and quite open to interpretation.
- I’ll review Matthew Poon & Michael Schutz’s fascinating paper, in Frontiers, Cueing musical emotions: An empirical analysis of 24-piece sets by Bach and Chopin documents parallels with emotional speech:
Using our operationalized definitions of pitch height and timing, we found that
– 1. major key pieces were in fact 29% faster in attack rate than minor (however, we note that this difference was driven entirely by Bach). Additionally,
- major key pieces in this corpus were approximately a major second (i.e., two halfsteps) higher – a distance previously shown sufficient to evoke changes in emotional tenor (Ilie and Thompson, 2006).
and I’ll explain why that matters.
2. CNN, AOL, Yahoo, and many other websites covered the cognitive shuffle
I was interviewed recently by CNN about the cognitive shuffle. The article appeared on Tuesday: “Cognitive shuffling: A mental trick to help you sleep | CNN“. This was actually quite a good article, though they got the order of my papers wrong.
I was happy that they noted that my original impetus to develop strategies to facilitate sleep-onset was motivated by the example of Prof. Claude Lamontagne. Lamontagne developed a detailed computational theory of the visual motion perception system from which he derived a novel set of predictions about conditions that would provoke an illusion of motion, which he called the sigma effect. (Not to be confused with the same effect in education.) They even linked to his Ph.D. thesis: Steps towards a computational theory of visual motion detection: designing a working system – University of Edinburgh, which I would recommend to anyone interested in computational psychology or theoretical AI. The predictions were proven true by Lamontagne and several others after him.
Claude Lamontagne contributed an incomplete chapter to my new book, Discontinuities: Love, Art, Mind. Sadly for all of us, Claude died in January of this year. You can read my obituary to him: Obituary for Dr. Claude Lamontagne, Retired Professor of Psychology at the University of Ottawa | by Luc P. Beaudoin | Mar, 2025 | Medium.
I thought to myself, if we understand the sleep onset control system (SOCS) well enough, we may be able to find conditions under which the SOCS can be tricked into triggering sleep onset. The theory I developed makes such a prediction, which is that cognitive shuffling can facilitate sleep onset in that manner.
3. Pre-print to my somnolent information processing theory paper
You can read about my theory and the cognitive shuffle here:
that paper will appear in D. Kay (Ed.) The Cambridge Handbook of Sleep Theories and Models. Cambridge University Press.
4. Detailed functional specification for Hookmark
I wrote a new detailed functional specification outlining major upgrades to the contextual information retrieval window (“context window”). The goal is for Hookmark no longer to give a mere No linkable item found in app message in app when it cannot resolve the foreground information resource (e.g., because the foreground document has never been saved or the foreground app is no link-friendly).
This was a major highlight of my week. I totally enjoy writing specifications for our software. It is meditative deep work.
We are also planning a super major enhancement to Hookmark which I cannot yet disclose ☹️ .
I also worked on Hookmark for iPhone & iPad, which is due for release later this month !
I also worked on Hookmark 6.9, due before end of the month as well.
5. On the receiving end of professional coaching
I’ve hired a professional coach, someone I can discuss how to balance the various aspects of my professional life at:
- CogZest (authoring and publishing my books),
- CogSci Apps Corp. (Hookmark and mySleepButton),
- Simon Fraser University (research mainly on sleep onset and insomnolence, information management, and emotions). I updated my SFU profile page, which required going to SFU in person since my VPN access is not working,
- Somnolence+ as mentioned below.
She will help me prioritize my interrelated projects.
6. A new book proposal in progress
I intend to write a book on falling asleep. More on this soon. But in a nutshell it will focus on sleep onset and insomnolence. That’s the focus. But I argue that to understand sleep onset and insomnolence you need to take an integrative design-oriented approach. As such the book will delve into consciousness, motivation and emotion, explaining how the sleep onset control system considers them. It will also have sleep hacks, including the cognitive shuffle.
7. Somnolence+
I also spent several hours (maybe too many hours) in communications with colleagues at Somnolence+, where I am a scientific consultant.
